When Fox News host and commentator Will Cain talks about his personal life, he rarely pulls punches about his past mistakes. Among his most frequently cited life lessons is his relationship with his wife, Kathleen Cain. Long before they settled down and built a family together in Texas, their relationship went through a dramatic collegiate breakup that included Kathleen briefly dating an Olympic athlete. Understanding the full story behind Will Cain and his wife requires looking past the public headlines into a narrative of youthful immaturity, a five-year hiatus, and a second chance at romance.
College Roots at Pepperdine University
The story of Will and Kathleen began during their undergraduate years at Pepperdine University in Malibu, California. As college sweethearts, they struck up an initial connection that felt promising. However, the relationship stalled due to timing and personal readiness.
Will has been transparent in past interviews, including discussions with ESPN, admitting that he simply wasn't mature enough for Kathleen during their initial college days. Recognizing that the relationship lacked the stability required for a long-term future, Kathleen ended the romance.
The Olympian Chapter
Following her split from Will, Kathleen moved forward and entered a relationship with an elite athlete—specifically, an Olympic volleyball player. While media reports and Will himself have touched upon this chapter, details regarding the Olympian's identity remain private, as Kathleen has consistently maintained a quiet personal life away from the public eye. That high-profile relationship ultimately ran its course as well, leaving Kathleen single as she navigated post-college life.
The Five-Year Separation and Reunion in Texas
Fate intervened half a decade after their initial college breakup. Both Will and Kathleen found themselves living in Texas, where their paths crossed once again.
By this time, the personal dynamics had shifted significantly:
- Personal Growth: Will had matured during the intervening five years, gaining the perspective and stability he lacked in college.
- Geographic Timing: Reconnecting in Texas provided a neutral, grounded environment away from the fast-paced backdrop of Malibu.
- Renewed Intentions: Recognizing their shared history, the two quickly realized the connection was worth a second chance.
Reflecting on the reunion later, Will famously noted that marrying Kathleen was the single best accomplishment of his life, framing the eventual success of their relationship around the resilience of their second chance.
Family Life and Public Privacy
Unlike many media personalities who leverage their spouses and children for brand building, Will and Kathleen take a distinctly private approach to family life. Kathleen maintains a low profile, keeping her personal social media accounts private and focusing her energy on family and philanthropy.
The couple shares two sons, Charlie and West. While Will occasionally shares brief glimpses of their travels—such as family trips to Hawaii or outdoor excursions—he respects his wife's preference to stay out of the media spotlight. Beyond her role as a mother, Kathleen has engaged in charitable efforts, including running the New York City Marathon to raise awareness and support for DEBRA International, an organization dedicated to fighting Epidermolysis Bullosa, a rare and painful skin disorder.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Will Cain's wife?
Will Cain is married to Kathleen Cain, his college sweetheart from Pepperdine University. They reconnected years later in Texas after a prolonged breakup.
Did Kathleen Cain really date an Olympian?
Yes. After parting ways with Will during their college years, Kathleen dated an Olympic volleyball player before that relationship ended and she eventually reunited with Will.
How many children do Will and Kathleen Cain have?
The couple shares two sons, Charlie and West.
What does Kathleen Cain do for a living?
Kathleen maintains a private professional life and focuses heavily on raising their children and participating in philanthropic work, such as running marathons for medical charities.
