Bravo's short-lived 2009 reality experiment tried to capture the hyper-privileged universe of Manhattan teenagers. While it only lasted a single season, the show left a permanent stamp on early-streaming pop culture. Viewers often wonder what happened to the teenage personalities after the cameras stopped rolling and the elite school doors closed.
Most of the original cast members traded reality television for corporate careers, quiet family lives, and private social media profiles. From fashion industry roles to real estate leadership, here is where the main cast members of NYC Prep ended up years after the show aired.
Jessie Leavitt: Pursuing Fashion in New York City
On the show, Jessica "Jessie" Leavitt was defined by her passion for high fashion, an enviable wardrobe, and front-row access to New York style events. Unlike many reality stars who chase fame long-term, Jessie channeled her screen experience back into her original career ambition.
After high school, she attended the Fashion Institute of Technology (FIT) in New York to study marketing and communications. She transitioned into professional visual merchandising for luxury brands, including Chanel. On the personal front, she married investment analyst Jason Brown in June 2019, settling down in the city where her fashion journey started.
Sebastian Oppenheim: Real Estate and Family Life
Often dubbed the show's answer to Chuck Bass, Sebastian Oppenheim spent his time on screen chasing romance and leaning into his prep school persona. Following the cancellation, he briefly stayed in the Bravo family by interning for Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live in 2013.
He later attended the College of Charleston to study international relations. Today, Sebastian works in the New York property sector, serving as a head of real estate for Rove. He married media personality Skyler Bouchard in 2019, and the couple welcomed their first child, a son named Arlo, in December 2023.
Camille Hughes: Corporate Success on the West Coast
Camille Isobel Hughes famously viewed her time on the show as an extracurricular activity, though the notoriety complicated her initial college outreach. She eventually attended the College of William & Mary in Virginia, graduating with a degree in neuroscience.
Relocating to Southern California, Camille built a successful corporate path in product and brand development within the health and wellness sector. She married Michael Paquette, and they welcomed a son on Christmas Day in 2023. She occasionally pokes fun at her reality TV past in her social media bios.
PC Peterson: Billionaire Roots and Quiet Living
Peter Cary "PC" Peterson came to the show with significant family legacy, being the grandson of billionaire Blackstone co-founder Pete Peterson. His time on screen involved plenty of social drama and theatrical ambitions.
As an adult, PC largely stepped away from the public eye. In 2018, he married longtime friend Quentin Esme Brown in a heavily publicized Las Vegas ceremony where Tiffany Trump served as a flower girl. The couple later filed for divorce in 2020, and PC has since maintained a private lifestyle focused on personal creative pursuits.
Kelli Brooke Tomashoff: Pursuing Music
Kelli Brooke Tomashoff experienced some of the show's most intense social friction, including a fallout with her prestigious day school. Following graduation, she leaned heavily into her artistic ambitions.
She enrolled in The New School and briefly pursued a professional music career. In 2011, she released an independent dance-pop single titled "Gave Up On Love," which landed minor traction on club charts. She has since kept a relatively low profile away from the entertainment industry.
Taylor DiGiovanni: Choosing Complete Privacy
As the cast member who attended a public alternative high school, Taylor DiGiovanni often played the outsider perspective on elite Manhattan social codes. While her iconic party-planning episodes remain fan favorites, she made a firm break from public life once filming wrapped.
Taylor completely exited the spotlight, keeping her personal social media channels locked and private. Unlike her castmates who integrated into public professional networks, she chose total anonymity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I stream NYC Prep today?
You can stream the complete first season of NYC Prep on Peacock, which added the series to its vault alongside other classic 2000s reality programs.
Why was NYC Prep canceled after one season?
Despite generating significant pop culture curiosity and online commentary, the show suffered from low television ratings during its initial 2009 broadcast run and faced intense pushback from real Manhattan private schools that refused to be associated with the drama.
Are any of the NYC Prep cast members still close?
Most of the cast members went their separate ways after filming wrapped, attending different colleges across the country and pursuing distinct corporate or creative industries. They do not maintain an active public group dynamic.
Did Taylor DiGiovanni ever return to social media?
No. Out of all the main cast members, Taylor remains the only one who completely avoided public-facing career profiles and social media visibility after the show ended.
