When CBS first brought the global dating phenomenon across the Atlantic in the summer of 2019, nobody knew how American audiences would react to the Fiji villa. Years later, reality television enthusiasts still wonder what happened to the original group of islanders. Zero couples from Season 1 remain together, but the cast has hardly faded into total obscurity.
Elizabeth Weber and Zac Mirabelli walked away as the inaugural champions, splitting the hundred-thousand-dollar cash prize. Yet, like almost every romance born under those studio lights, their relationship fizzled out within months of leaving Fiji. From high-profile spin-off shows to entirely new career paths in business and fashion, here is the real update on where the Season 1 cast members ended up.
The Winning Couple: Elizabeth Weber and Zac Mirabelli
Elizabeth and Zac felt like an instant match, capturing America's votes with their early chemistry and drama-free trajectory. They even exchanged "I love yous" inside the villa.
Post-show reality proved different from Fiji. By December 2019, the pair announced their amicable split, citing conflicting life paths.
- Elizabeth Weber: Elizabeth transitioned into full-time modeling, working with prominent brands like Adidas and Dr. Martens. She also co-hosted the After the Island podcast. In her personal life, Elizabeth got engaged to Hotstreak Fantasy Sports co-founder Gianni Settino.
- Zac Mirabelli: Zac kept a much lower profile after the breakup. He signed with Ford Models New York, landed fashion magazine covers, and stepped away from the intense spotlight of weekly reality television.
The Runners-Up: Alexandra Stewart and Dylan Curry
Alexandra and Dylan secured second place after a solid run that won over viewers who preferred a steady connection over chaotic twists.
- Alexandra Stewart: Alexandra remained deeply connected to the franchise. Alongside Elizabeth, she hosted After the Island and frequently covers current seasons on social media. She also released music, dropping her debut single "Didn't Deserve It".
- Dylan Curry: Dylan returned to his athletic roots away from Hollywood. He plays lacrosse for the San Diego Lacrosse Club and works with CrossFit TurnPoint. He maintains a quiet social media presence compared to his fellow finalists.
Third Place and Fan Favorites: Caro Viehweg and Ray Gantt
Caro and Ray brought immense personality to Season 1, finishing in third place and later taking their relationship to another CBS reality staple, The Amazing Race.
- Caroline "Caro" Viehweg: Caro's time on The Amazing Race was cut short by pandemic production shutdowns, and she split from Ray in July 2020. Caro found her lasting happy ending off-screen. She married entrepreneur Rene Lacad in 2023 and welcomed a daughter named Amina in April 2024.
- Raymond "Ray" Gantt: Ray stayed in the reality television ecosystem. He returned for Love Island Games Season 1, competed on MTV's Ex on the Beach, and joined the cast of Netflix's Perfect Match in search of a match.
Weston Richey and Emily Salch
Weston entered on Day 1 and ultimately coupled up with bombshell Emily Salch, finishing in fourth place. Distance and conflicting personalities caused them to separate by Valentine's Day in 2020.
- Emily Salch: Emily transitioned into entrepreneurship, founding a skincare line called Face-y Company. She also appeared on Love Island Games and shares lifestyle content online.
- Weston Richey: Weston launched XclusiV Productions in 2021, focusing on commercial filmmaking and creative documentary projects.
Kyra Green and Cashel Barnett
Few relationships on the show experienced as much turbulence as Kyra and Cashel's on-and-off dynamic. They split shortly after the season wrapped.
- Kyra Green: Kyra built a massive social media following, competed on MTV's The Challenge: USA, and returned for Love Island Games. In her personal life, Kyra came out as bisexual and celebrated milestones with her girlfriend, Tal Sahar.
- Cashel Barnett: Cashel also appeared on The Challenge: USA, plays drums in his band Doom Cupcake, and works with modeling agencies on the West Coast.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are any couples from Love Island USA Season 1 still together?
No. Every single couple formed during the inaugural 2019 season has broken up. While seasons from later years have produced marriages and long-term partnerships, Season 1 relationships proved to be purely seasonal. You can browse past episode summaries directly on Peacock.
Who won Love Island USA Season 1?
Elizabeth Weber and Zac Mirabelli won the first season on August 7, 2019, after receiving the highest percentage of public votes. They chose to split the $100,000 prize before breaking up a few months later.
Which Season 1 cast members returned for other reality shows?
Several alumni refused to leave the network television circuit. Ray Gantt, Kyra Green, and Emily Salch all returned for Love Island Games. Additionally, Ray, Kyra, and Cashel Barnett appeared on various crossover competition series like The Challenge: USA and Ex on the Beach.
Did any cast members leave reality TV entirely?
Yes. Winners like Zac Mirabelli and finalists like Dylan Curry largely stepped away from the public eye, choosing traditional career paths in modeling, fitness, and local athletics rather than pursuing a full-time influencer lifestyle.
